AUTOSSL sni not redirecting

Hello all,

I've got the following issue :

I have a VPS with WHM 64on CENTOS 7.3. This server is hosting 50+ websites/accounts/domains. Each domain has it's own SSL certificate through auto SSL.

However when trying to reach a certain domain/website through Https i get an error SSL_ERROR_BAD_CERT_DOMAIN because the certificate relates to my server name (vps.servername.com) instead of the domain of the website (example.com)

The certificate for the domain is valid.
Always redirect to SSL/TLS in tweaksettings is on
The server IP is dedicated and shared with the websites/domains

It seems to work for some domains, not for other.
The domains that do not work have following options different as the domains that do work :
- Is Primary Website on IP Address? Yes
- Is SNI Required? No
Where with the domains that are working it's the opposite.

But I can't change these options ...

Any pointers would be great.