setup dns cluster correctly

[NeoNomad]

Hey guys,

i already have read the documentation but their is still a understanding problem and the first problem occured. I think i need some help to getting started correct.

What i want to setup:

• cPanel & WHM Server for Hosting purposes (cp1.domain.tld)
• cPanel DNSOnly as ns1 (ns1.domain.tld)
• cPanel DNSOnly as ns2 (ns2.domain.tld)
• cp1.domain.tld should use ns1 and ns2

What i already did:

1. Setup rDNS on dedicated and 2 cloud servers to the hostname for ipv4 and ipv6
2. Installed cPanel & WHM to dedicated server (Ubuntu 20.04) via this article
3. Installed DNSOnly to 2 cloud servers (Ubuntu 20.04) via this article
4. Logged in to all three interfaces and changed password
5. Logged in to all three interfaces and set the hostname
6. Logged in to all three interfaces and set the record for the hostname
7. Logged in to all three interfaces and configured e-mail addresses and ipv6 in Basic WebHost Manager
8. Logged in to all three interfaces and configured nameservers to ns1.domain.tld and ns2.domain.tld in Basic WebHost Manager
9. Logged in to both DNSOnly interfaces and created API Key for DNS Clustering Access Control List (ACL) privilege
10. Logged in to cPanel & WHM Server, enabled DNS Cluster and added both ns servers with API key in standalone mode and with Reverse Trust Relationship
11. QUESTION: Should i disable DNS on cPanel & WHM Server so that only both nameservers are the nameservers of my cPanel & WHM server?
12. Use WHM’s Synchronize DNS Records interface to manually synchronize each new nameserver with the DNS cluster
13. Logged in to SSH on cPanel & WHM server, entered dig +short ns1.domain.tld @ip.of.ns1.server and dig +short ns2.domain.tld @ip.of.ns2.server. ns1 responded with the ip of ns1 and ns2 responded with the ip of ns2
14. Registered ns1.domain.tld and ns2.domain.tld in combination with their ip addresses at my registrar (hetzner)

So my question:

• is anything still missing or wrong to use ns1.domain.tld and ns2.domain.tld at my hostname-domain and on domains i want to host in cpanel?

Cause when i try to change the nameservers of my hostname-domain with correct glue records, i get the following error:

response:
result:
code: '2305'
msg: 'Object association prohibits operation'
extValue:
-
value: ERROR
reason: 'Nameserver error [ERROR: 133 Answer must be authoritative (nameserver, ip, proto, record) (ns2.domain.tld, ip.of.ns.2, udp, NS)]'
-
value: ERROR
reason: 'Nameserver error [ERROR: 901 Unexpected RCODE (nameserver, ip, proto, record) (ns2.domain.tld, ip.of.ns.2, udp, NS)]'
-
value: ERROR
reason: 'Nameserver error [ERROR: 133 Answer must be authoritative (nameserver, ip, proto, record) (ns1.domain.tld, ip.of.ns.1, udp, NS)]'
-
value: ERROR
reason: 'Nameserver error [ERROR: 901 Unexpected RCODE (nameserver, ip, proto, record) (ns1.domain.tld, ip.of.ns.1, udp, NS)]'
-
value: ERROR
reason: "Nameserver error [ERROR: 106 Inconsistent set of nameserver IP addresses (ns, provided_ips, determined_ips) (ns2.domain.tld, ['ip.of.ns.2'], ['ip.of.ns.2', 'ipv6.of.ns.2'])]"
-
value: ERROR
reason: "Nameserver error [ERROR: 106 Inconsistent set of nameserver IP addresses (ns, provided_ips, determined_ips) (ns1.domain.tld, ['ip.of.ns.1'], ['ip.of.ns.1', 'ipv6.of.ns.1'])]"
-
value: ERROR
reason: 'Nameserver error [ERROR: 901 Unexpected RCODE (target, entity, rcode) (ip.of.ns.2, SOA, REFUSED)]'
-
value: ERROR
reason: 'Nameserver error [ERROR: 901 Unexpected RCODE (target, entity, rcode) (ip.of.ns.1, SOA, REFUSED)]'

 

[NeoNomad]

It seems nobody can help...I solved on my own...The zone for domain.tld was needed to create and add NS/A/AAAA Records für ns1 and ns2. Futher i needed to switch to "synchronize changes" in dns clustering.

 

[cPRex]

I'm glad you were able to track that down!

 

[airbytes]

It seems nobody can help...I solved on my own...The zone for domain.tld was needed to create and add NS/A/AAAA Records für ns1 and ns2. Futher i needed to switch to "synchronize changes" in dns clustering.

Hi NeoNomad,

Did you switched into "Synchronize Changes" on NS1 and NS2 hosts or on CP1 hosts?

Thanks

 

[airbytes]

I'm glad you were able to track that down!

Maybe you have an idea ?

 

[cPRex]

@airbytes - I don't have any ideas based on the details provided. What issues are you seeing with the cluster on your end?